The question as used in the run (Polish)#
Postanowienie o odrzuceniu zażalenia (SA) - brak opłaty, czy przysługuje zażalenie ?
Original wording, exactly as the lawyer typed it into the chat (Polish); typos kept.
The trap
The question contains no false premise. It measures hitting the core and the correctness of citations.
The correct answer according to the key#
Core answer. It depends on which complaint the court of appeal rejected. If it was a complaint to another panel of the second-instance court (art. 394² § 1 or § 1¹ of the Code of Civil Procedure), a single judge rejects it, and that order can be challenged by a complaint to another panel of the court of appeal (art. 394² § 1², second sentence).
Required bases. art. 394² § 1² Code of Civil Procedure; art. 397 § 1¹ Code of Civil Procedure
Expected calibration: conditional. type of complaint rejected: to another panel of the court of appeal (art. 394² § 1 or § 1¹) → a complaint is available (§ 1², second sentence); a complaint against a regional-court order rejected by the court of appeal as second instance (art. 397 § 1¹) → not available
The full key (rubric, penalties, quotation patterns from the source, known rulings) is in the repository in keys/P06_odrzucenie_zazalenia_SA.yaml. Every legal basis was checked in the official text as of the legal-state date. Rules of the key.
Results of the eight models#
| Model | Condition | Block A % | Result | Card |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| GPT-6.1 Sol | W0 | 22 | T | card |
| W1 | 78 | ✓ | card | |
| GPT-6 Astra | W0 | 44 | W | card |
| W1 | 50 | – | card | |
| GPT-5.6 Terra | W0 | 11 | F | card |
| W1 | 78 | ✓ | card | |
| Claude Opus 5.5 | W0 | 6 | TW | card |
| W1 | 61 | W | card | |
| Claude Sonnet 5.5 | W0 | 17 | TW | card |
| W1 | 67 | W | card | |
| Claude Haiku 5.5 | W0 | 17 | T | card |
| W1 | 17 | T | card | |
| Gemini 3.8 Flash | W0 | 6 | T | card |
| W1 | 75 | ✓ | card | |
| Gemini 4 Argon | W0 | 17 | SW | card |
| W1 | 75 | T | card |
correctly groundedno hallucination; not correctly groundedhallucinatedprovider blockColumns: models in report order; rows: W0 no tools, W1 with web search.
✓ correctly grounded · – no hallucination, but the core is incomplete or no source was checked · T W F S error classes in a hallucinated answer (definitions) · block text blocked by the provider's filter, no label · block A = criteria checked against the key and the source (scoring criteria)
The numbers concern one answer of each model to this question in each condition. They say nothing about run-to-run variance or about other questions in this field.